This cinnamon coffee cake is a gentle, comforting bake with warm cinnamon, a soft crumb, and a sweet streusel that fills the kitchen with a peaceful, homey feeling. It’s the kind of recipe that brings a little calm into the day, simple to make and easy to share with the people around you. The flavors are warm and familiar, and the whole bake has that quiet, cozy touch that makes it feel special without being complicated.
Mary shows us how quiet, ordinary moments can become places of grace, simply by being present and steady in them. Her life wasn’t loud or dramatic; it was shaped by small acts of care, patience, and trust. When we bake or create something with our hands, there’s a little echo of that same calm spirit — a reminder that simple work done with a peaceful heart can draw us closer to God in the middle of everyday life.
In my personal opinion, I think a good coffee cake should have nice plush cake, a beautiful cinnamon-sugar ripple in the middle, and a buttery cinnamon streusel topping! This cake is perfect for any time of year but would be the perfect unique Valentine dessert! (In case you're tired of strawberries and chocolate!) 😉
Why you'll love this recipe:
-Secret ingredient for extra flavor & plush! Many coffee cakes rely on sour cream and buttermilk for a nice tender plush cake. BUT we are doing something different! We are adding cream cheese to the cake batter which makes this coffee cake the ACTUAL BEST COFFEE CAKE!! 😊And not to mention, it stays soft for days... (maybe it won't last that long!)
-Buttermilk without baking soda! So, in many recipes (like in my Banana Muffins) we combine buttermilk with baking soda for an acidic reaction that makes whatever we're making have a nice lift...NOT TODAY! We're not even using baking soda today, we're just relying on buttermilk to add a nice plush crumb. Kind of cream cheese, but together = the best coffee cake!
-Bake in whichever pan you have or need! I like to bake this in a 9x9 inch cake pan, BUT you can absolutely use a 9x13 inch cake pan! Whichever will work, I prefer metal, but glass will work.
-No pastry cutter needed! Best part! In many streusel recipes, you need a pastry cutter, but I don't have one so the kind of method I'll be showing you will be using melted butter. Adds a much richer and buttery streusel topping than using cold butter! 😍
What you're going to need:
Cream cheese- just talked about it...this is our secret weapon that makes this coffee cake so moist, melt-in-your-mouth delicious! Don't substitute, don't skip it, don't ignore it! You really need it for the best coffee cake. Don't use the tub like container because it has other additives that we don't need. Instead stick with full fat block cream cheese!
Sugar- Other coffee cake recipes use all granulated sugar. But I like a dense, (yet soft!) cake. And to achieve that, we add a lot of brown sugar (1 cup), and this not only enhances the flavor a lot, but makes the cake delicious! If you know me well, you know I love to use a combination of light brown sugar & granulated sugar. It gives us the best of both flavors!
Cornstarch- this secret ingredient elevates our coffee cake next level. I love using it on my Chocolate Chip Muffins, because it makes our cake moist and soft for days. I love using it anywhere I can!
Buttermilk- While whole milk would "work", I like going the extra mile and using buttermilk. Buttermilk adds a nice flavor, moisture, and softness to the cake. A buttermilk substitute could work if you don't have real buttermilk on hand! (That's what I do, and if you want me to share a buttermilk substitute, please tell me! 🙂)
This batter will be thicker than what you may expect. Don't freak out! It is designed to be thick so we can have a nice smooth cake as the final result. Because of this, it will be tricky to spread the top layer of cake batter with the cinnamon-sugar ripple on the middle. But don't worry, it's possible! If you want a visual tutorial, you can check out my YouTube Channel.
How to make coffee cake:
-
Make the Batter & Cinnamon Ripple
-
Make the Streusel & Bake
This coffee cake is perfect as is, but if you want something extra, make a super easy glaze with just 2 ingredients!
-
powdered sugar
-
milk
Many recipes, you have to be careful not to overmix. Here, there's no worry, but you do have to be careful not to overbake. If your cake turns out dry or dense, it means it was baked too long! To avoid this, keep an eye on your cake.
Frequently asked questions:
There’s something quietly comforting about a recipe like this coffee cake — the kind that fills the kitchen with warmth and reminds you to slow down for a moment. As the cinnamon melts into the batter and the crumb topping turns golden, it becomes a small invitation to enjoy the simple things: a warm slice, a calm morning, and the sweetness that finds its way into everyday life.
Related Recipes:
Add comment
Comments